On Asking Oneself Questions

titleOn Asking Oneself Questions
start_date2025/11/14
schedule12h
onlineno
location_infosalle Langevin
summaryWhat does a successful intellectual life consist in? Certainly, it involves having the right cognitive attitudes — attitudes that are properly responsive to the evidence one possesses. But a successful intellectual life is also one in which inquiries (i.e. the search for new evidence) are properly pursued. In my talk, I will focus on the norms that govern inquiry. This is one of the most debated topics in current epistemology (the so-called zetetic turn). However, while epistemologists usually propose norms of inquiry that tell us when inquiry should not be undertaken, I would like, in this presentation, to propose a positive norm — a norm that tells us when we ought to inquire. In short, I will defend the idea that one ought to inquire into the answer to a question whenever one asks oneself that question. Just as the illocutionary act of promising gives rise to obligations, so too does the act of asking oneself a question generate a requirement to seek evidential reasons in order to answer the question posed.
responsiblesBuehler